If you searched for PIP because you have just received one, you probably do not need another explanation of what the abbreviation means.
You already know.
Performance Improvement Plan.
The real question is:
Is this really about improving your performance – or are you already one step closer to losing your job?
Recently, I have received several employment law enquiries involving PIPs. In some cases, the PIP was still ongoing. In others, the story eventually ended with the termination of employment.
The cases I have seen so far involved companies with an American background. This is not particularly surprising. In my own practice, I have typically seen PIPs in this type of corporate environment. So far, I have not come across one at a Hungarian-owned company.
Of course, companies evaluate employee performance in many other ways: annual or semi-annual performance reviews, KPIs, targets, management assessments or bonus-related objectives.
A PIP is just one of these tools.
The name matters less than what is actually happening in your employment relationship.
PIPs do not have a particularly good reputation
If you work for a multinational company, there is a good chance you had already heard about PIPs long before your own name appeared on one.
From a colleague. A former colleague. A friend. Or someone who “had exactly the same thing happen at their company.”
And let’s be fair, these stories rarely start with:
“Guess what, John was put on a PIP. Lucky him.”
PIPs come with a fairly strong negative association. By the time you receive one, somebody has probably already told you:
“They are preparing to fire you.”
Someone else may have suggested that it is time to update your CV. And there is a reason why this reputation exists.
A PIP can be part of a process that eventually leads to the termination of employment.
The employer may use the process to record performance issues, expectations and results. Later, the situation may move towards termination or discussions about a mutual agreement. But there is one important word in that sentence:
Can.
Not every PIP means that a final decision to terminate your employment has already been made. But let’s look at the other side for a moment. There is something interesting about the way we tend to look at employers. We naturally expect our employer to pay our salary every month, provide proper working conditions and fulfil its obligations towards us.
But when the employer says that something is not good enough, or that it expects something different from our work, it can very quickly become the villain of the story.
However, an employer being dissatisfied with an employee’s performance does not automatically mean that the employee is being treated unfairly.
Employment is a two-way relationship. Employees have legitimate expectations towards their employer, but employers can also have legitimate expectations regarding employee performance.
You may believe that you are doing a good job.
You may have received positive feedback before.
But your employer may genuinely see a problem with your performance. And the PIP may be exactly what its name suggests: a process in which the employer expects you to improve something.
That should not automatically be interpreted as bad faith.
Do not ignore it either
There is a reason the word Improvement is part of the name. If you receive a PIP, it is reasonable to assume that your employer is dissatisfied with something and expects a change.
That alone is enough reason to take it seriously. Not because you will definitely be fired. But because the person evaluating your work has effectively told you:
Something needs to change.
There are two extreme reactions that are equally unhelpful.
“I received a PIP, so they are definitely going to fire me.”
and
“This is nonsense. I am doing a good job, so I can ignore it.”
Neither is particularly useful.
“But they always told me I was doing a good job.”
Now it becomes more interesting. If you previously received good evaluations, met your targets and had positive feedback, and suddenly a very different picture of your performance appears, it is completely understandable to ask:
Perhaps your performance really has changed.
Perhaps the expectations have changed.
Perhaps a new manager evaluates your work differently.
And yes, it is also possible that the PIP is already part of a process that may later lead to the termination of your employment.
None of these possibilities should automatically be treated as the answer.
A negative PIP result and termination of employment are not the same thing. But they can be connected.
Performance problems, evaluations and other circumstances recorded during the PIP may later become relevant to decisions made by the employer.
Under Hungarian employment law, issues relating to an employee’s performance or conduct may, depending on the circumstances, also become relevant when an employer terminates an employment relationship.
Whether a particular termination is lawful, however, is a separate legal question. So there is no simple formula:
Failed PIP = automatic termination
That equation does not exist. But it would be equally wrong to assume that the outcome of a PIP can never have consequences later.
I would put it simply:
Don’t panic. But take it seriously.
Do not assume that you are definitely going to lose your job. But do not assume that you definitely will not.
And do not automatically assume that if your employer raises a performance problem, the employer must be the bad guy.
There may be a genuine performance issue. There may be a misunderstanding. Expectations may have changed. Or the PIP may already be part of a longer process leading towards an employment decision.
The three letters “PIP” alone cannot tell you which one applies to your situation.
If you have already listened to your colleagues, your friends and that one person whose friend was “fired in exactly the same way”, but you are still asking yourself:
“Okay. But what is happening in my case?”
then you probably do not need another general story about PIPs. You need someone to look at your situation.
Every PIP has a context. A case-specific review can tell you much more than the three letters at the top of the document.
This article provides general information only. The assessment of an individual employment law matter always depends on the specific circumstances and documents of the case.
Discuss Your Case