Hu

Firing Employees in Hungary: Can Being Too Nice Backfire?


Why being a fair and understanding employer is not always enough to avoid employment disputes in Hungary.

“Everybody lies.”

Anyone who has watched House M.D. will probably remember this line. It was one of Dr. House’s favorite sayings. Someone I know likes to repeat it, too. I have always found it a rather extreme view of human nature, and to be fair, I still do not want to accept it as a general truth.

I tend to believe that people act in good faith. And although it may not always look that way, I am actually someone who prefers to avoid conflict. (I know, some people reading this are probably laughing right now.)

But it is true.

On the other hand, I would not describe myself as a particularly patient person. I do not think these two things contradict each other. I do not like creating unnecessary conflicts, but when something needs to be resolved, I do not believe in putting it off forever.

Perhaps this is why I find it difficult to understand employers who keep delaying uncomfortable decisions.

I understand good intentions, flexibility, and giving an employee a second or even a third chance. But there must be a limit. If the same problem keeps coming back, and previous discussions, warnings, or compromises have not worked, sooner or later a decision must be made. Not necessarily to terminate the employment, but certainly not to leave the situation unchanged.

Because avoiding a conflict and solving a problem are not the same thing.

Over the years, I have learned one important lesson: just because we act in good faith does not mean the other person will see the situation in the same way.

In this respect, an employment relationship is surprisingly similar to a romantic relationship.

At the beginning, there is trust, mutual sympathy, shared goals, and a little bit of that honeymoon feeling. Then time passes, the first disappointments appear, and the parties slowly discover that they may have very different ideas about cooperation, flexibility, and fair treatment.

And when the relationship breaks down, they may no longer tell the same story about their shared past.

In an employment lawsuit, it is not necessarily the most convincing story that matters. What matters is which legally relevant facts can be proven.

When an Employer Tries to Be Understanding for Too Long

A common situation in employment disputes is that an employer has been unhappy with an employee's performance or behavior for a long time but has not taken clear action.

The employee may regularly make mistakes, fail to meet expectations, have difficulties working with colleagues, or simply fail to perform at the level reasonably expected for the position.

The manager talks to the employee. Gives another chance. Takes personal circumstances into account. Perhaps even reduces the workload for a while. The manager does not want to write a formal report after every conversation. After all, the goal is not to prepare for a future lawsuit. The goal is to keep the employee.

So far, this is understandable.

But what happens when nothing changes?

Another discussion, another promise, another chance. Months pass, the same problems remain, and the employer continues to hope that things will eventually improve.

At this point, I no longer necessarily see kindness. I see a decision being delayed. An employer has responsibilities not only toward one employee, but also toward the rest of the team, the organization, and the business itself.

When someone consistently fails to meet expectations, other people often pay the price. Colleagues correct mistakes, take over tasks, and managers spend more and more time dealing with the same problems. 

After a while, unlimited patience is not necessarily fair treatment.

And when the employer finally decides to terminate the employment, it may become clear that there is very little written evidence of the problems that have continued for months.

Everyone Remembers It, but Nobody Wrote It Down

For the employer, the termination is the result of a long process.

The manager remembers the conversations. HR knows about the problems. Colleagues understand why working together has become difficult.

But the employee may remember things very differently.

The employer says the employee was told several times that their performance was not good enough. The employee says these were only general discussions and nobody explained that their job might be at risk.

The employer believes clear expectations were communicated. The employee says nobody explained exactly what needed to change.

And perhaps neither party is deliberately lying. They simply remember the same events differently and give them different meanings.

But in an employment lawsuit, saying "everyone knew about it" is not enough.

The question becomes: what can actually be proven?

A Different Story May Begin When Termination Becomes a Possibility

There is another side to these cases that I find particularly interesting.

When termination becomes a real possibility, the attitudes of both parties may change.

Past events that previously seemed unimportant may suddenly become relevant. A manager's comment that could be understood in different ways, an old disagreement, an email, or a situation that the employer originally saw very differently.

Sometimes an employee may also disclose health issues or personal difficulties that the employer did not previously know about, or did not fully understand.

Of course, these circumstances may be entirely genuine and legally relevant. An employer cannot simply ignore them because they were raised shortly before termination.

However, they may make the situation much more complicated.

What originally looked like a straightforward performance issue may develop into a legal dispute about what the employer knew, when the employer knew it, how the employer responded, and whether the stated reason was the real reason for termination.

This does not automatically mean the employer acted unlawfully.

But it does mean that when an employment relationship has been poorly documented, establishing what actually happened may become much more difficult.

In Hungary, Employers Must Be Able to Prove Their Reasons for Termination

This is especially important for foreign companies employing people in Hungary, particularly when their managers are familiar with employment practices in other countries.

Under Hungarian employment law, employers are generally required to provide reasons when terminating an employment relationship by notice.

Those reasons must be clear, genuine, and reasonably connected to the termination.

If the employee challenges the termination in court, the employer must prove that the stated reasons are true and justify the decision.

However, Hungarian law does not generally require every employer termination to be preceded by a written warning or a formal Performance Improvement Plan (PIP).

The absence of these steps does not automatically make a termination unlawful. The real problem arises when an employer has genuine performance concerns but cannot provide sufficient evidence to support them.

And this is where earlier kindness may become a disadvantage.

The employer tolerated the situation for months because they wanted to give the employee another chance. Later, however, a question may arise: if the problems were really that serious, why did the employer not take action earlier?

Being patient for a long time does not, by itself, prevent an employer from lawfully terminating employment.

But inconsistent communication and missing documentation can create serious difficulties when the employer must prove the reasons for the decision.

A Lawyer Cannot Rewrite the Past

Employers often contact a lawyer only after they have already decided to terminate an employee.

At that point, the most important question is not always how to write the termination letter.

It is what evidence supports the decision.

What expectations were communicated to the employee? When and how were the problems discussed? Were performance reviews carried out? Are there emails, written records, or other evidence?

And just as importantly, are the available facts actually sufficient to support a lawful termination?

A carefully written termination letter cannot replace missing facts. A lawyer can help assess the legal risks, choose an appropriate solution, and prepare the necessary documents. But a lawyer cannot go back in time and create performance discussions that never took place.

Employers Do Not Need to Be Suspicious. They Need to Be Consistent.

I do not believe employers should automatically distrust their employees. Nor do I think every small mistake should become a formal HR matter.

A healthy workplace needs trust, flexibility, and understanding. But trust should not mean that an employer fails to set clear expectations, avoids giving honest feedback, or does not document serious problems.

Especially when termination may become a possibility.

Employees also benefit from knowing exactly what is expected of them, why their employer is unhappy, and what needs to change.

For employers, consistent management is not only an organizational matter. It is also a legal one.

Proper documentation cannot guarantee that an employer will never face an employment lawsuit. But it can make it much easier to prove the facts behind a decision if a dispute arises.

And perhaps this brings us back to the statement at the beginning.

“Everybody lies.”

I still do not believe that is true. But I am increasingly convinced that when a relationship breaks down, the people involved may remember events differently and may have very different ideas about what is fair.

That is why employers should not assume the worst about everyone. Instead, they should recognize when understanding is no longer enough, make the necessary decisions in time, and ensure those decisions can also stand up to legal scrutiny.

Because in an employment lawsuit, an employer does not need to prove that they were a good person. They need to prove that they acted lawfully.

Do Not Wait Until an Employment Decision Becomes a Legal Dispute

If your company employs people in Hungary, it is worth reviewing the legal risks before making a termination decision. We provide legal support to employers in managing performance issues, preparing employment decisions, and handling lawful employment termination under Hungarian law.

Discuss Your Case ← Back to All Insights

RELATED INSIGHTS

PRIVATE LEGAL CONSULTATION

Legal clarity starts with a conversation.

Independent legal advice for international clients and businesses in Hungary.

Explore your options ↗